Corresponding
Author: Muhammad Hasan Suryawan
E-mail:
[email protected]
INTRODUCTION
This introduction describes social change as a natural
phenomenon in people's lives
Some of the factors that drive social change in
society include discoveries, population increases, conflicts, revolutions, and
people's openness to outside influences
However, social
change does not only have a positive impact on the development of human
civilization
In the
Indonesian context, pesantren has a long history as an educational institution
that not only educates but also functions as an agent of social change. Since
its inception, pesantren has become an integral part of social change in
Indonesia. In the 19th century, pesantren became the center of resistance to
colonial colonialism and played a role in the struggle for Indonesian
independence. After independence, Islamic boarding schools continued their role
as Islamic educational institutions that fought for the values of patriotism
and nationality.
Islamic boarding
schools also continue to adapt to social changes
In 2002, the
Indonesian government issued an equality policy (muadalah) for pesantren
graduates to support pesantren's existence in the national education system.
However, this policy reaped pros and cons among Islamic boarding schools. Some
Islamic boarding schools reject this policy because it is considered irrelevant
to their education system; it is feared that it will erode the uniqueness and
independence of Islamic boarding schools and has the potential to change the
intellectual traditions that have long developed in Islamic boarding schools
Nonetheless,
social changes in society have prompted many Islamic boarding schools to
consider transforming their education systems. According to Dhofier, changes
and developments in the orientation of pesantren must always be oriented to
social changes and the needs of the community, considering that pesantren have
become an inseparable part of social traditions in Indonesia. Therefore,
pesantren needs to maintain the relevance of their educational vision and goals
in community development
The question
then arises of how it can maintain its existence as a transformative
educational institution that contributes to social change
Kuntowijoyo, in
the concept of prophetic Islam or transformative Islam, emphasized that Islamic
teachings must be able to answer the challenges of social life through
objectification between normative values in Islam and existing social
realities. Thus, Islamic boarding schools, as Islamic educational institutions,
must be able to produce graduates who are sensitive to social problems and
contribute to solving these problems
Mahmud Arif
Other studies
also show that pesantren have great potential as agents of social change.
Najihatul Fadhliyah, in his dissertation on the transformative-transcendent
education model in Islamic boarding schools, emphasized the importance of
internalizing prophetic values in producing graduates who become agents of
social change. Fahrurrozi, in his study of pesantren in Lombok, West Nusa
Tenggara, found that pesantren play a role as a catalyst for social change
through the expansion of its function from a mere religious institution to a
social institution that plays a role in various aspects of people's lives.
Wajdi
This research is
important to understand how pesantren, through their role and function as
educational institutions and social institutions, can remain relevant to the
social changes that occur in society
The primary objective of this study is to compare the
transformative education approaches of Nurul Haramain NW Narmada and Thohir
Yasin Lendang Nangka pesantren
Comparing these two pesantren is crucial in the context of
transformative education because they represent different approaches to
navigating the challenges posed by modernity while remaining true to their
Islamic foundations
METHODS
The
approach used in this study is qualitative with the type of field research
The qualitative data for
this study were collected through a combination of in-depth interviews,
participant observation, document analysis, and focus group discussions (FGDs),
all of which aimed to comprehensively explore the transformative processes at
the Nurul Haramain NW Narmada and Thohir Yasin Lendang Nangka pesantren.
In-depth interviews were conducted with key informants, including pesantren
leaders, teachers, students, alumni, and community members, using
semi-structured questions to gather diverse perspectives on educational
innovations and social impacts. Additionally, multiple site visits were made to
observe classroom interactions, vocational training programs, and community
engagement activities, allowing for a deeper understanding of the integration
of traditional and modern educational practices. The research also involved
document analysis of institutional records, including curricula and historical
documents, to contextualize the pesantren's development. FGDs with students,
teachers, and alumni provided further insights into how the transformative
education model influenced personal and community development, while informal
interviews with local community members helped gauge the broader societal
impact of pesantren graduates. All data were analyzed thematically, identifying
key patterns related to educational transformation, community engagement, and
the balance between religious and secular education, ensuring a comprehensive
and credible understanding of the research objectives.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Transformation
of Islamic Boarding Schools for Social Change
Pesantren have historically served as centers of Islamic learning and
social transformation. Their influence extends beyond mere education, as they
shape the moral and ethical frameworks of individuals and the broader society.
Over time, many pesantren have embraced the challenge of remaining relevant in
an ever-evolving socio-cultural landscape. The transformation witnessed in both
Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin Pesantren illustrates the adaptive nature of
these institutions, highlighting their responsiveness to global trends while
preserving the essence of Islamic tradition.
The transformation of these pesantren is multifaceted, involving changes
in curricula, teaching methods, institutional management, and community
engagement. At the core of these transformations is integrating secular and
religious education, which has become a hallmark of modern pesantren. By
offering students the opportunity to study subjects such as mathematics,
science, and technology alongside traditional religious studies, these
institutions equip their students to navigate the complexities of modern life
while remaining firmly grounded in their faith.
One of the key aspects of this transformation is the introduction of
vocational training programs. At Nurul Haramain, students participate in
vocational courses in areas such as agriculture, carpentry, and technology,
which not only prepare them for employment but also empower them to contribute
to their communities. Similarly, Thohir Yasin has integrated vocational
training into its curriculum, offering students practical skills that
complement their religious education. These programs are designed to foster a
sense of independence and responsibility, enabling students to apply their
knowledge and skills in meaningful ways after graduation.
The transformation at both pesantren is not limited to educational
content. These institutions have also made significant strides in updating
their infrastructure and teaching methodologies. Nurul Haramain, for example,
has embraced technology in its classrooms, equipping them with digital tools
that facilitate modern learning. The use of information technology allows
students to access a wealth of resources online, enhancing their educational
experience. Thohir Yasin, while more cautious in its adoption of technology, is
beginning to explore the use of digital tools in its teaching practices,
particularly in the digitization of traditional Islamic texts.
These changes reflect a broader trend in Indonesian education, where
pesantren are increasingly seen as agents of social change. By equipping
students with religious and secular knowledge, these institutions are preparing
them to contribute to their communities in various ways, from economic
development to environmental conservation. The dual focus on education and
community engagement ensures that pesantren graduates are well-rounded
individuals and active participants in the broader societal transformation.
Institutional
Transformation and Community Impact
The institutional transformations at Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin
have had far-reaching effects, both within the institutions and in the
surrounding communities. The research reveals that both pesantren have embraced
a model of education that balances religious instruction with practical,
real-world applications. This balance is evident in the variety of vocational
training programs offered at both institutions, which range from agricultural
practices to modern technological skills.
At Nurul Haramain, for instance, students engage in practical training
that includes carpentry, computer programming, and agricultural management.
These skills are not only valuable for the students themselves but also for the
broader community, as many graduates return to their villages to apply their
knowledge in ways that benefit the local economy. This emphasis on community
engagement is a defining feature of the pesantren’s educational philosophy, as
it seeks to produce graduates who are not only knowledgeable but also socially
responsible.
Thohir Yasin, while similar in its approach, places a particular
emphasis on formal education. The pesantren has established several formal
institutions within its framework, including Ma'had Aly, a higher education
institution that focuses on Islamic studies. This formalization of education
within the pesantren structure allows Thohir Yasin to offer a more structured
and comprehensive learning experience, preparing students for leadership roles
in both religious and secular contexts. The institutional transformation at
Thohir Yasin is particularly noteworthy for its focus on integrating
traditional Islamic education with modern pedagogical methods, creating a
unique blend of old and new that appeals to both students and the wider
community.
The impact of these transformations extends beyond the confines of the
pesantren. Graduates from both institutions are playing key roles in their
communities, whether through economic development initiatives, religious
outreach, or environmental programs. For example, Nurul Haramain’s “Green
Haramain” initiative has had a significant impact on environmental
sustainability in the region, promoting tree planting and conservation efforts
that have been embraced by both students and residents. Similarly, Thohir Yasin
has contributed to local development through its emphasis on entrepreneurship
and community service, encouraging students to take an active role in
addressing the needs of their communities.
The impact of
these transformations extends beyond the walls of the pesantren, influencing
not only the students but also the surrounding communities. At Nurul Haramain,
transformative education is characterized by a strong integration of vocational
training programs in areas such as agriculture, carpentry, and technology,
where students gain practical skills that prepare them for both employment and
community leadership. This pesantren has invested in modern learning
infrastructure, equipping classrooms with digital tools to facilitate
contemporary learning. For example, students use these technologies to access
online resources and engage in project-based learning, which fosters critical
thinking and problem-solving. In contrast, Thohir Yasin Pesantren maintains a
more traditional approach, with an emphasis on classical Islamic education, but
has gradually integrated modern pedagogical methods. While it has been slower
to adopt digital technologies, Thohir Yasin focuses on entrepreneurship
training, encouraging students to develop skills that will allow them to create
economic opportunities in their communities. A notable similarity between both
pesantren is their dual commitment to religious and secular education, with
both institutions balancing these areas to produce well-rounded graduates.
However,
while Nurul Haramain emphasizes technological innovation and vocational
readiness, Thohir Yasin places greater emphasis on preserving traditional
religious practices while slowly incorporating elements of modern education.
Despite these differences, both pesantren show a strong commitment to
empowering their students to become agents of social change, evident in the
success of their graduates who have returned to their communities to lead
initiatives in environmental conservation and economic development, such as
Nurul Haramain's Green Haramain project and Thohir Yasin's community business
cooperatives. These examples underscore both the distinct and shared aspects of
transformative education in these institutions, where both modern and
traditional methods are employed to foster social and economic progress.
This focus on community involvement is a hallmark of both pesantren’s
educational models. By encouraging students to apply their knowledge and skills
in service of the community, these institutions are fostering a sense of social
responsibility that extends far beyond the classroom. The success of this model
is evident in the growing number of graduates who are returning to their
communities to lead initiatives in areas such as economic empowerment,
religious education, and environmental conservation.
Scientific
Development in the Pesantren
The scientific development within both Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin
pesantren is a key aspect of their educational transformation. The integration
of modern scientific reasoning with traditional Islamic epistemology is central
to the pesantren’s approach to education. This integration is achieved through
a comprehensive approach that includes three main pillars: Bayani, Burhani, and
Irfani reasoning.
Bayani reasoning is rooted in the study of religious texts, such as the
Quran, Hadith, and classical Islamic jurisprudence. This form of reasoning
emphasizes the importance of understanding the foundational texts of Islam,
which are seen as the basis for all knowledge. At both Nurul Haramain and
Thohir Yasin, Bayani’s reasoning is reinforced through studying classical
Islamic texts, with a particular emphasis on mastering Arabic and other
essential religious sciences. The goal is to ensure that students are
well-versed in the religious knowledge that forms the core of their faith.
Burhani reasoning, on the other hand, is more focused on logical and
scientific inquiry. This form of reasoning equips students with the skills
needed to engage with modern disciplines such as mathematics, natural sciences,
and social sciences. Both Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin have incorporated
Burhani reasoning into their curricula by offering subjects that promote
critical thinking and scientific inquiry. For example, students at Nurul
Haramain study subjects such as mathematics, physics, and biology, which are
integrated into the broader educational framework. Similarly, Thohir Yasin
offers courses in logic, mathematics, and philosophy, providing students with
the tools to engage in rigorous intellectual exploration.
Irfani reasoning, the third pillar, emphasizes spiritual and ethical
development. This form of reasoning is concerned with the cultivation of moral
and spiritual values, which are seen as essential for personal and societal
well-being. At both pesantren, Irfani’s reasoning is reinforced through daily
religious practices such as prayer, fasting, and Quran recitation. These
activities foster a deep connection between students and their faith,
encouraging them to live ethical and spiritually fulfilling lives. In addition
to formal religious practices, both pesantren offer opportunities for students
to engage in spiritual reflection through retreats and other forms of spiritual
training.
Combining these three forms of reasoning—Bayani, Burhani, and
Irfani—creates a well-rounded educational experience that prepares students for
success in both religious and secular contexts. By integrating traditional
Islamic epistemology with modern scientific reasoning, both Nurul Haramain and
Thohir Yasin are equipping their students with the skills needed to navigate
the complexities of contemporary society while remaining true to their
religious values.
Learning
Innovations
As the demands of modern education continue to evolve, both Nurul
Haramain and Thohir Yasin have introduced significant learning innovations to
keep pace with these changes. One of the most notable innovations at Nurul
Haramain is integrating digital technology into the classroom. Classrooms at
Nurul Haramain are equipped with state-of-the-art digital tools that enhance
the learning experience, allowing students and teachers to access a wide range
of educational resources online. This shift towards digitization reflects a
broader trend in global education, where technology is increasingly used to
facilitate learning and improve academic outcomes.
At Thohir Yasin, the introduction of digital tools has been more
gradual. The pesantren is exploring ways to digitize its curriculum,
particularly about the study of classical Islamic texts. While technology in
religious education is still a relatively new concept, Thohir Yasin is
committed to incorporating digital tools into its teaching practices without
compromising the integrity of its religious instruction. This cautious approach
reflects the pesantren’s commitment to maintaining the balance between tradition
and modernity, ensuring that students receive a comprehensive education that
includes both religious and secular knowledge.
In addition to technological innovations, both pesantren have introduced
new teaching methods designed to improve student engagement and learning
outcomes. At Nurul Haramain, for example, teachers use a variety of interactive
teaching methods, including group work, discussions, and hands-on activities.
These methods encourage students to take an active role in their learning,
fostering critical thinking and problem-solving skills. Similarly, Thohir Yasin
has adopted a more student-centered approach to teaching, with a focus on
dialogue, discussion, and experiential learning. This shift towards more
interactive teaching methods reflects a growing recognition of the importance
of active learning in promoting student success.
The introduction of new learning methods at both pesantren has also been
accompanied by changes in the way students are assessed. At Nurul Haramain, for
example, students are evaluated not only through traditional exams but also
through project-based assessments and presentations. This approach allows
students to demonstrate their understanding of key concepts in a more practical
and applied manner. Thohir Yasin has also introduced new assessment methods,
including oral exams and practical demonstrations, which provide a more
holistic view of student learning and progress.
These innovations in teaching and assessment are part of a broader
effort to modernize the educational system at both pesantren. By adopting new
technologies and teaching methods, Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin are ensuring
that their students are well-prepared to meet the challenges of a rapidly
changing world. However, both institutions remain committed to maintaining the
core values of their religious tradition, ensuring that the modern innovations
introduced do not undermine the spiritual and moral development of their
students.
Vocational
Training and Community Engagement
One of the key findings of this research is the role of vocational
training in empowering students and supporting community development. Both
Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin have made vocational training a central part of
their educational programs, providing students with practical skills that can
be applied in real-world settings. These programs are designed not only to
prepare students for future employment but also to foster a sense of
independence and self-reliance, enabling them to contribute meaningfully to
their communities.
At Nurul Haramain, vocational training programs include courses in
agriculture, carpentry, and technology, among others. These programs are
designed to equip students with the skills needed to succeed in a variety of
fields while also promoting a sense of responsibility and social awareness.
Many graduates of Nurul Haramain return to their communities to apply their
skills in ways that benefit the local economy, whether by starting their
businesses or participating in community development projects.
Thohir Yasin, while similar in its approach, places a particular
emphasis on entrepreneurship and economic empowerment. The pesantren offers
vocational training programs that focus on developing entrepreneurial skills,
encouraging students to think critically about how they can use their knowledge
and skills to create economic opportunities for themselves and others. This
emphasis on entrepreneurship reflects the pesantren’s commitment to promoting
self-reliance and economic independence, particularly in rural communities
where job opportunities may be limited.
In addition to vocational training, both pesantren place a strong
emphasis on community engagement. Graduates of Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin
are encouraged to take an active role in their communities, whether through
religious outreach, economic development initiatives, or environmental
conservation efforts. For example, many graduates of Nurul Haramain have become
leaders in local environmental programs, helping to promote sustainability and
conservation efforts in their communities. Similarly, graduates of Thohir Yasin
have played key roles in promoting economic empowerment through the
establishment of local businesses and cooperatives.
This focus on community engagement is a defining feature of both
pesantren’s educational models. By encouraging students to apply their
knowledge and skills in service of their communities, these institutions are
fostering a sense of social responsibility that extends far beyond the
classroom. The success of this model is evident in the growing number of
graduates who are returning to their communities to lead initiatives in areas
such as economic empowerment, religious education, and environmental sustainability.
Graduates
as Agents of Social Change
The transformative education provided by Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin
equips graduates to act as agents of social change. These graduates possess a
unique combination of religious knowledge, vocational skills, and a commitment
to social improvement, making them well-suited to address the challenges facing
their communities. The research reveals that many graduates of both pesantren
have returned to their communities to lead initiatives aimed at promoting
economic development, religious education, and environmental sustainability.
At Nurul Haramain, graduates have been instrumental in the development
of local businesses and cooperatives, contributing to the economic well-being
of their communities. Many of these graduates have used the skills they
acquired during their time at the pesantren to start their businesses, creating
job opportunities for others and helping to strengthen the local economy. In
addition to their economic contributions, these graduates have also played key
roles in promoting environmental sustainability, particularly through the
“Green Haramain” initiative, which has had a significant impact on
environmental conservation efforts in the region.
Graduates of Thohir Yasin have similarly made important contributions to
their communities, particularly in the areas of religious education and
economic empowerment. Many of these graduates have become leaders in local
religious organizations, using their knowledge of Islamic teachings to promote
ethical and moral values within their communities. In addition, graduates of
Thohir Yasin have played key roles in promoting entrepreneurship and economic
development, helping to establish local businesses and cooperatives that
provide economic opportunities for others.
The research suggests that the transformative education provided by
these pesantren is not only preparing students for personal success but also
empowering them to contribute positively to their communities. By producing
graduates who are both knowledgeable and socially responsible, Nurul Haramain
and Thohir Yasin are playing a vital role in promoting social change and
community development in Indonesia.
Discussion
on Educational Transformation
The findings of this research highlight the success of the educational
transformations at Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin. Both pesantren have
demonstrated that it is possible to integrate modern education with traditional
Islamic values in a way that benefits both students and society. By offering a
balanced curriculum that includes both religious and general education, these
pesantren are preparing students to navigate the complexities of modern life
while remaining grounded in their faith.
However, the process of transformation has its challenges. One of the
main challenges faced by both pesantren is maintaining the balance between
tradition and modernity. While both institutions have embraced modern
educational practices, some stakeholders are concerned that the introduction of
modern curricula may dilute the pesantren's religious focus. This tension
between maintaining tradition and embracing change will likely continue as
pesantren navigate the demands of a rapidly changing world.
Despite these challenges, the research suggests that the transformations
at Nurul Haramain and Thohir Yasin have been largely successful. Both
institutions have adapted to modern society's needs without losing sight of
their core religious values. This adaptability is key to their success, as it
allows them to provide students with a comprehensive education that prepares
them for both religious and secular life.
In conclusion, the transformative education provided by Nurul Haramain
and Thohir Yasin benefits not only students but also has a profound impact on
the wider community. By producing graduates who are knowledgeable, skilled, and
committed to social change, these pesantren continue to play a vital role in
the development of Indonesian society.
CONCLUSION
The conclusion of this study highlights
the successful scientific development and institutional transformation efforts
carried out by the Nurul Haramain NW Narmada and Thohir Yasin Lendang Nangka
Islamic Boarding Schools to prepare graduates as agents of social change. These
pesantren have adopted a comprehensive approach to scientific reasoning,
including Bayani, Burhani, and Irfan methodologies, alongside extracurricular
programs aimed at fostering students' potential and enhancing their community
development skills. Institutional transformation involves strengthening both
formal and non-formal educational systems, reforming educational services, and
adopting professional management practices. These efforts extend to community
development initiatives, particularly in economics, education, da'wah, and
environmental preservation. Furthermore, both pesantren have implemented
innovative learning strategies, emphasizing religious and general subjects,
vocational training, and Islamic values. Nurul Haramain has focused on
improving infrastructure and technology, while Thohir Yasin has preserved
traditional methods, such as classical studies. Graduates from both
institutions possess well-rounded skills and ethical foundations, equipping
them to contribute to societal progress in education, politics, economics, and
culture. The transformations have positively impacted broader communities
through economic growth, social da'wah, and environmental conservation. To
build on these findings, policymakers should create supportive policies for
integrating modern vocational training and technology into pesantren while
maintaining core religious values. Educators should adopt interactive teaching
methods and balance religious and secular knowledge, while administrators
should focus on curriculum development, infrastructure improvement, and
community engagement. By implementing these recommendations, pesantren can
continue to empower students and contribute to sustainable social and economic
development in Indonesia, ensuring their relevance in an ever-evolving society.
REFERENCES
Abu-Rayya, M. H., Walker, R., White, F.
A., & Abu-Rayya, H. M. (2016). Cultural identification and religious
identification contribute differentially to the adaptation of Australian
adolescent Muslims. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 54,
21–33.
Aidulsyah, F. (2023). The rise of urban
Salafism in Indonesia: The social-media and pop culture of new Indonesian
Islamic youth. Asian Journal of Social Science, 51(4), 252–259.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajss.2023.07.003
Alfaro-Navarro, J. L., López-Ruiz, V.
R., Huete-Alcocer, N., & Nevado-Peña, D. (2024). Quality of life in the
urban context within the paradigm of digital human capital. Cities, 153.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2024.105284
Asadullah, M. N., & Chaudhury, N.
(2010). Religious schools, social values, and economic attitudes: Evidence
from Bangladesh. World Development, 38(2), 205–217.
Baron, R. A. (2004). The cognitive
perspective: a valuable tool for answering entrepreneurship’s basic “why”
questions. Journal of Business Venturing, 19(2), 221–239.
Bergert, A., Welleschik, L., &
Ditye, T. (2024). “Why can’t I say people’s names?” Alexinomia as a widespread
psychological phenomenon. Acta Psychologica, 246.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104279
Boubker, O. (2024). Does religion raise
entrepreneurial intention and behavior of Muslim university students? An
extension of Ajzen’s theory of planned behavior (TPB). International
Journal of Management Education, 22(3).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijme.2024.101030
Campo, E., Ballester, J., Langlois, J.,
Dacremont, C., & Valentin, D. (2010). Comparison of conventional
descriptive analysis and a citation frequency-based descriptive method for
odor profiling: An application to Burgundy Pinot noir wines. Food Quality
and Preference, 21(1), 44–55.
Chappin, E. J. L., & Ligtvoet, A.
(2014). Transition and transformation: A bibliometric analysis of two
scientific networks researching socio-technical change. Renewable and
Sustainable Energy Reviews, 30, 715–723.
Coates, T. T., & McDermott, C. M.
(2002). An exploratory analysis of new competencies: a resource
based view perspective. Journal of Operations Management, 20(5),
435–450.
Coccia, M. (2014). Driving forces of
technological change: The relation between population growth and technological
innovation: Analysis of the optimal interaction across countries. Technological
Forecasting and Social Change, 82, 52–65.
Cutler, N. A., Halcomb, E., & Sim,
J. (2023). Using naturalistic inquiry to inform qualitative description. Nurse
Researcher, 31(3).
Dallh, M. (2023). Accumulate but
Distribute: Islamic Emphasis on the Establishment of Waqf (Pious Endowment). Religion
and Development, 2(1), 21–40.
https://doi.org/10.30965/27507955-20230014
El Maaroufi, A. (2022). Towards an
Ethic of Being-With. An Islamic-Phenomenological Perspective on Human-Animal
Encounters. Journal of Islamic Ethics, 6(1), 81–93.
https://doi.org/10.1163/24685542-12340078
Farid, A., & Lamb, M. (2020).
English for Da’wah? L2 motivation in Indonesian pesantren schools. System,
94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2020.102310
Gan Yupanqui, K. R., Zeug, W., Thrän,
D., & Bezama, A. (2024). A regionalized social life cycle assessment of a
prospective value chain of second-generation biofuel production. Journal of
Cleaner Production, 472.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.143370
Indriasari, R., Fitayani, N. S.,
Mansur, M. A., & Tunru, A. (2020). Alarming nutrition problems among
adolescent students attending islamic boarding school in Indonesia. Enfermeria
Clinica, 30, 44–47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enfcli.2019.10.037
Licoppe, C., & Smoreda, Z. (2005).
Are social networks technologically embedded?: How
networks are changing today with changes in communication technology. Social
Networks, 27(4), 317–335.
Mertens, D. M. (2023). Research and
evaluation in education and psychology: Integrating diversity with
quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods. Sage publications.
Miranda-Lescano, R., Muinelo-Gallo, L.,
& Roca-Sagales, O. (2024). Human development and inequalities: The
importance of social public spending. Structural Change and Economic
Dynamics, 69, 363–377.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.strueco.2023.12.008
Prayitno, H. J., Markhamah, Nasucha,
Y., Huda, M., Ratih, K., Ubaidullah, Rohmadi, M., Boeriswati, E., &
Thambu, N. (2022). Prophetic educational values in the Indonesian language
textbook: pillars of positive politeness and character education. Heliyon,
8(8). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e10016
Shah, R., & Cardozo, M. L. (2014).
Education and social change in post-conflict and post-disaster Aceh,
Indonesia. International Journal of Educational Development, 38,
2–12.
Shin, J., Lew, Y. K., & Seo, M.
(2024). Constructing Muslim womanhood in Indonesia: Hijab and the
governmentality of religious organizations. Asian Journal of Social Science,
52(3), 136–144. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajss.2024.07.001
Sinuff, T., Cook, D. J., &
Giacomini, M. (2007). How qualitative research can contribute to research in
the intensive care unit. Journal of Critical Care, 22(2),
104–111.
Suski, P., Augenstein, K., &
Greiff, K. (2024). Life Cycle Assessment of Consumption Patterns –
Understanding the links between changing social practices and environmental
impacts. Journal of Cleaner Production, 477.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.143813
Um, Y. J. (2024). The effect of social
withdrawal on life satisfaction among multicultural adolescents: The mediating
and moderating effects of parental support. Heliyon, 10(19).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e38313
Wekke, I. S., & Hamid, S. (2013).
Technology on language teaching and learning: a research
on Indonesian pesantren. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 83,
585–589.
Wheeler, N. E., Allidina, S., Long, E.
U., Schneider, S. P., Haas, I. J., & Cunningham, W. A. (2020). Ideology
and predictive processing: coordination, bias, and polarization in socially
constrained error minimization. Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences,
34, 192–198. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cobeha.2020.05.002
You, L., & Liu, F. (2024). From
virtual voices to real impact: Authenticity, altruism, and egoism in social
advocacy by human and virtual influencers. Technological Forecasting and
Social Change, 207. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2024.123650
You, L., Zhao, X., & Xu, S. (2024).
How political ideology affects the communication of organizational relations:
A social network approach. Public Relations Review, 50(2).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2024.102451
Yusuf, M., & Wekke, I. S. (2015). Active learning on
teaching Arabic for special purpose in Indonesian Pesantren. Procedia-Social
and Behavioral Sciences, 191, 137–141.
|
|
© 2024 by
the authors. Submitted for possible open access publication under the terms
and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY SA) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/). |
