THE INFLUENCE
OF ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE AND WORK ETHICS ON LECTURERS' COMPETENCE AND
PERFORMANCE
Paulus L Wairisal
Pattimura University,
Ambon, Indonesia
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Organizational culture determines the
direction of individual behavior of an institution. This study aims to analyze
and explain the direct influence of organizational culture on competence and
the indirect influence of organizational culture on lecturer performance
through competence. Analyze and explain the direct effect of work ethic on
competence and the indirect effect of work ethic on lecturer performance
through competence. Analyze and explain the effect of competency on lecturer
performance. Method: This type of research is explanatory research with
a survey approach. The sampling technique is a saturated sample with a total of
72 lecturers as respondents. The type and source of data are Primary Data. Result:
The hypothesis test results prove that organizational culture has a
significant positive indirect effect on lecturer performance through competence
(0.031 <0.05). Work ethic significantly positively affects lecturer
performance through competence significance (0.019 <0.05). Competence has a
significant direct effect on performance (0.003 <0.05). Conclusion: Competence
has an intervening role in organizational culture and works ethic on lecturer
performance because it has a very high value. If the competency is increased by
one interval, the lecturer's performance will increase.
Keywords: Organizational Culture, Work Ethics, Competence, Lecturer Performance.
Corresponding Author: Paulus
L Wairisal
E-mail: [email protected]
INTRODUCTION
The organization is a system that influences each
other; if one of the sub-systems is damaged, it will affect the other
sub-systems (Dahlan et al., 2017). The system can run properly if the individuals in it
are obliged to manage it, which means that as long as the members or
individuals still like and carry out their responsibilities as they should, the
organization will run well (Ansen & Norman,
2016). The organization is also the determination and
grouping of work to be done, determines and delegates authority and responsibility
intending to enable people to work together effectively in achieving goals (Darim, 2020).
Human Resource is a strategic element in determining
whether or not an organization is healthy. Human resource development can be
understood as preparing individual employees to assume different or higher
responsibilities within the organization. Development usually relates to
increasing the intellectual or emotional abilities needed to do a better job.
The development of human resources is based on the fact that individual
employees need knowledge, expertise, and developing abilities to work well (Miftahudin, 2018).
Every individual always has different characteristics
from one. These traits can be characteristics of someone so that we can find
out how they are. As with humans, organizations also have specific
characteristics. We are familiar with the organizational or organizational
culture through these characteristics. The cultures that each ethnic group owns
have a system of values and norms governing each of its members from that tribe
and people from other tribes. Thus, an organization also has a culture that
regulates how its members act (Sustainable, 2022). Supported by a professional work ethic is a crucial
route to success. Without a professional work ethic, we might easily slip into
a line of losers. Without the inner awareness to project professionalism in all
bodies, we may soon become human beings who stutter with the dynamics of
change. Poor achievement and absence from the long journey to be productive,
noble and dignified. Employees with a high work ethic are reflected in their
behavior, such as working hard, being fair, not wasting time during working
hours, the desire to give more than what is hinted at, willingness to
cooperate, and respect for colleagues. The results of research conducted by (Suryadinata, 2015) concerning the influence of organizational culture,
organizational climate and work motivation on lecturer performance indicate
that an academic climate has not been created. Work standard is a parameter
that indicates the work ethic of academic staff is still low. In addition to
the low level of lecturer attendance, research results and academic staff
writings have not been published optimally because there is no integrated
management information system (MIS) for academic staff.
Competency factors can also influence improving
employee performance. Placing employees following their competence will be
decisive in creating maximum performance. Therefore the competency factor must
be a criterion that is considered in organizational activities. This will have
a positive impact on improving individual and organizational/group performance.
Because competence is an essential characteristic of a person (individual) that
influences how to think and act, generalizes to all situations encountered and
lasts quite a long time in humans (Rostiana &
Iskandar, 2020). The concept described above is a significant concern
that needs to be studied at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University
of Pattimura.
METHODS
This type of explanatory research survey approach.
Research Location at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura
University. The population is a combination of all elements in the form of events,
people with the characteristics of being the center of attention of researchers
(Hariyanti, 2021). The population in this research was 72 lecturers at the
Faculty of Teaching and Education at Pattimura University.
The sampling technique is a saturated sample in which 72 lecturers are used as
respondents. The types and sources of data are Primary Data, namely data
obtained directly through interviews with respondents or with the help of a
questionnaire list that has been compiled and distributed to respondents,
namely lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura University.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
1.
Path
Analysis Study Model
Pathways according
to the hypothesis that has been formulated are as follows:
Figure 1. Path Test Model
The
equation for the path analysis model is as follows:
Y1
= PY1.X1+ PY2.X2 + e
Y2
= PY2.X1+ PY2.X2+ e
The results of this
study have met the path analysis assumption test with BLUE requirements.
a.
Hypothesis
Testing 1
First
hypothesis: there is a significant direct influence between organizational
culture and work ethic on the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of
Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura
Recapitulation
of the results of the calculation of the first stage of the path or analysis of
the influence of organizational culture and work ethic on the competence of
lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura
Path analysis for
the first stage using the SPSS 21 program, as follows:
Table
1. Summary of First Stage Path Analysis Results
|
Dependent
variable |
Free
Variables |
Betas |
t |
Significant |
Information |
|
Y |
X1 |
0.786 |
5,129 |
0.027 |
Significant |
|
|
X2 |
0.661 |
6,962 |
0.031 |
Significant |
|
R
�������������������������������������� =
0.892 |
|||||
|
R
Square ������������������������������ =
0.627 |
|||||
|
Adjusted
R Square ��������������� =
0.643 |
|||||
Source: Primary
data processed in 2017
Based on table 1.
the results of the first stage path analysis statistical calculations above,
the following results are obtained:
1)
Organizational
culture directly influences the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of
Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura. This can be proven because the
significance value of t (0.027) <0.05.
2)
Work
ethic has a significant direct effect on the variable of lecturer competence at
the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura. This can be
proven where the significance value of t (0.031) <0.05.
So it can be
concluded that the hypothesis states that organizational culture and work ethic
have a significant direct influence on the competence of lecturers at the
Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura. Ha accepted (Ho
rejected).
b.
Hypothesis
Testing 2
The second hypothesis states that there is a
significant direct and indirect influence between organizational culture and
work ethic on lecturer performance variables through the competence of
lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura.
Recapitulation of the results of the second stage of the path calculation or
analysis of the influence of organizational culture and work ethic on lecturer
performance through the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and
Education, University of Pattimura. The second phase of path analysis uses the
SPSS 21 program, as follows:
Table 2. Recapitulation of the Results of the Second
Stage Path Analysis
|
Dependent
variable |
Free
Variables |
Betas |
t |
Significant |
Information |
|
Y2 |
X1 |
0.781 |
12,341 |
0.013 |
Significant |
|
|
X1 |
0.735 |
17,059 |
0.019 |
Significant |
|
|
Y2 |
0.886 |
11,549 |
0.003 |
Significant |
|
R
���������������������� = 0.898 |
|||||
|
R
Square �������������� = 0.876 |
|||||
|
Adjusted
R Square � = 0.851 |
|||||
The following results are obtained based on table 2.
a recapitulation of the calculation results of the second stage path analysis
above.
1)
Organizational
culture has a significant direct and indirect influence on lecturer performance
through the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education,
University of Pattimura. This can be proven where the significance value of t
(0.013) <0.05.
2)
Work
ethic has a significant direct and indirect influence on lecturer performance
through the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education,
University of Pattimura. This can be proven by the significance value of t
(0.019) <0.05.
So based on the results of the second stage test, it
can be concluded that the hypothesis states that there is a direct and indirect
significant influence between organizational culture on lecturer performance
through the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education,
University of Pattimura. Ha accepted (Ho rejected).
c.
Hypothesis
Testing 3
The third hypothesis states a significant direct
influence between lecturer competence and lecturer performance at the Faculty
of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura. The results of the third
stage of hypothesis testing were obtained from the results of the second stage.
Based on the results of statistical calculations in the second stage of path
analysis above, the following results are obtained: competence has a
significant direct influence on the performance of lecturers at the Teaching
and Education Faculty of Patimura University. Where is the significance value
of t (0.003) <0.05? So it can be concluded that the third hypothesis can be
accepted (Ho is rejected) or there is a significant direct influence between
competence on the performance of lecturers at the Faculty of Teacher Training
and Education, University of Pattimura.
2.
The
Influence of Organizational Culture on Lecturer Performance at the Faculty of
Teacher Training and Education, Patimura University
The
results of this study prove that organizational culture has a significant
positive direct effect on competency value significance (0.027 <0.05).
Organizational culture has a significant positive indirect effect on lecturer
performance through competence. Significant value (0.013 < 0.05) The results
of this study prove that organizational culture indications include workplace
formality and structure, work procedures are the primary reference in work,
leaders are coordinators and regulators, the main concern and are long-term in
terms of efficient performance, criteria success is in the delivery of reliable
results, good scheduling and efficient costs that apply and are interpreted by
all elements of the organization affecting the performance of lecturers at the
Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, Patimura University.
The
results of this study prove that organizational culture is indicated in terms
of workplace formality and structure, work guidelines based on applicable work
procedures, the role of leaders as work coordinators and regulators, and the
primary concern of all long-term employees on efficient performance is work
patterns. These assumptions underlie work activities are developed and applied
in the organization. Operationally the organizational culture of the lecturers
at the Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, University of Pattimura, is
realized comprehensively in terms of adequate and suitable workplaces,
lecturers work following procedures, leaders coordinating and managing the
running of offices, efficient work plans, achieving quality performance,
achieving good performance. On-time. Leaders encourage lecturers to be
efficient and have clear and measurable goals. Achieving maximum performance is
the responsibility of employees. In order to encourage the achievement of
maximum lecturer performance, lecturers at the Faculty of Teacher Training and
Education, University of Pattimura, create a shared understanding among
employees about how organizations work and how employees should behave. The
results of this study reveal the basic assumptions found or developed by
lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura, to
solve problems, adapt to the external environment and integrate with the
internal environment. In principle, the implementation of organizational
culture at the Teaching and Education Faculty, Pattimura University,
concentrates on the behavior or process of an employee in carrying out tasks,
not solely focusing on employee factors. The Teaching and Education Faculty at
Pattimura University does not focus on personal attributes but focuses on the
factor of how individuals or groups of employees work so that the factors,
basic assumptions and organizational dimensions that focus on internal
orientation and organizational integration interests, external orientation on
organizational differentiation interests and orientations that focus on
stability and control as well as the flexibility and flexibility that
ultimately shape the characteristics of the lecturer at work. The description
of the fact of the implementation of organizational culture is justified as a
perspective of understanding the behavior of individuals or groups of lecturers
about work so that, directly or indirectly, it can improve lecturer performance
through the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education,
University of Pattimura.
The
results of descriptive calculations justify this fact; it is illustrated that the majority of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and
Education at Pattimura University have worked for more than five years; this
condition illustrates that the majority of lecturers have interpreted systems,
norms, rules, beliefs, and shared expectations that shape the
character/behavior in the organization. The results of this study explain the
meaning of the values and assumptions that the workplace is adequate and
reasonable, employees work according to procedures, leaders coordinate and
manage the running of offices, efficient work plans, achieve quality
performance, achieve performance on time are interpreted strongly. The
togetherness of individual employees and the intensity or degree of employee
commitment supports comprehensiveness. The results of this study are in line
with (Edison et al.,
2016), which state that organizational culture is what
employees perceive and the way that perception creates a pattern of beliefs,
values and expectations.
The
results of this study prove that the implementation and meaning of
organizational culture at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura
University, as a guideline for the behavior of individuals and groups of
lecturers has proven to influence employee loyalty, work performance,
responsibility for work/main tasks, obedience to rules, honesty, cooperation
teamwork), work initiatives/innovations which are indications of lecturer
performance. The results of this study are consistent with the results of a
study (Ainanur &
Tirtayasa, 2018) which proves that the influence between
organizational culture, leadership and competence has a significant effect on
employee performance. The results of this study support the research results of
Xenikou and Simosi (2006), proving that organizational culture influences
employee performance in several financial business units in Greece. The results
of this study support the results of the study (Purwitasari, 2021), proving that organizational culture influences
employee performance through BUMD.
The
results of this study are in contrast to the results of a study by Brackertz
(2006), which proves that aspects of physical performance affect the
performance of public servants in Australia, the results of the study found
that better physical facilities provide better results of public services by officials.
3.
The
Effect of Work Ethics on Lecturer Performance at the Teaching and Education
Faculty of Patimura University
Based on the results of statistical tests prove that
work ethic has a significant positive direct effect on competence (0.031 <0.05).
Work ethic has a positive direct and indirect effect on lecturer performance
through competence (0.031 <0.05). Hypothesis accepted. This shows that the
indicators/items work sincerely, work with gratitude, the work is completed
thoroughly, the work the lecturer does requires perseverance, work with passion
and responsibility, the lecturer's work is a means of respecting the abilities
of others, giving opportunities for other people will increase lecturer
satisfaction at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura University.
This research proves that the work ethic applied by
lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura University, has
been very well received by all employees; thus, implementing a good work ethic
will improve the performance of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and
Education, Pattimura University.
Descriptively, the respondents' responses to the
work ethic as a whole, the average respondent said was very good; this is shown
in the mean value of 4.32. This research proves that the implementation of the
lecturer's work ethic at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura
University, has been carried out very well so that it can improve lecturer
performance through the competence of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and
Education, Pattimura University. This study supports the results of research (Yantika et al.,
2018), showing that higher or lower individual
performance can be due to work ethic.
4.
The
Effect of Competence on Lecturer Performance at the Patimura Teaching and
Education Faculty
Based on the results of statistical competency
tests, it has a significant and positive influence on the performance of
lecturers at the Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, the University of
Pattimura (0.003<0.05). Hypothesis accepted. This shows that competency with
item knowledge indicators: work is completed according to the knowledge
possessed, understanding administration systems at work, and understanding
service systems at work that are good at work will improve the performance of
lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura.
Competence with skill indicators of work items that are completed according to
ability and work that is completed according to skills will improve the
performance of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University
of Pattimura. Competency with self-concept indicators items: comply with social
norms in carrying out work, work according to applicable regulations,
indicators of personal characteristics items: always responsive to conditions
in the workplace, given information in completing work. Will improve the
performance of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, Pattimura
University. Competence with motive item indicators: in completing work, always
controlling emotions, and always prioritizing the public interest will improve
the performance of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education,
University of Pattimura.
Descriptively, the respondent's response to the
lecturer competence variable at the Faculty of Teacher Training and Education,
University of Pattimura, on average, the respondents stated that it was very
good/good, this is indicated by the mean value: 4.2. The results of this study
explain that the competence possessed by lecturers will improve the performance
of lecturers at the Faculty of Teaching and Education, University of Pattimura.
This study rejects the results of research (Ayu, 2020) entitled the effect of Loyalty and Employee
Competence on Public Service Performance. Kampar Regency Mining Sub-District
Office. The research results state that there is no influence exerted by
variable X (employee competence) on variable Y (public service performance).
This fact explains that employee competence (variable X) has no significant
effect on the performance of public services (variable Y). This study supports
the results of research (Nurmasitha, 2013) conducted a study entitled The Influence of
Competence and Work Environment on Service Performance (Study at the Sidoarjo
Regency Population and Civil Registration Service). The competence variable's
positive effect on the service quality of the Population and Civil Registry
Office of Sidoarjo Regency is favorable. This study also supports the concept
developed by Michael Zwell (2000:56-68). Competence is not an ability that
cannot be influenced. Several factors can affect a person's competency skills,
namely: beliefs and values, skills, experience, personality characteristics,
motivation, emotional issues, intellectual abilities, and organizational
culture that employees must have (Mujiatun, 2017).
And also, this research supports the concepts
developed by (Rohida, 2018) competencies that can be developed to improve
employee performance, namely knowledge, referring to information and learning
outcomes, skills, referring to a person's ability to carry out an activity;
self-concept and values refer to attitudes, values and self-image of a person,
Personal characteristics, refers to physical characteristics and consistency of
responses to situations or information, motives, our motivations, desires,
psychological needs, or other impulses that trigger action.
CONCLUSION
Descriptively, respondents'
responses to organizational culture agreed with a mean value of 3.91.
Organizational culture with indicators: systems, norms, rules, beliefs, and
shared expectations have a significantly positive effect on competence.
Organizational culture has a significant positive indirect effect on lecturer
performance through competence. Descriptively, the respondents' responses to
the work ethic stated that they strongly agreed with the mean value of 4.32.
Work ethic with work indicators is grace, and work is a calling. Work is
actualization; work is service has a direct and significant positive effect on
competence. Work ethic has a significant positive indirect effect on lecturer
performance through competence. Respondents' responses to competency stated
that they strongly agreed with the mean value of 4.21. and lecturer performance
means the value of 4.11. Competency with indicators: Knowledge, skills,
concepts, personal characteristics, and motives have a significant effect on
lecturer performance with indicators: loyalty, work performance,
responsibility, obedience, honesty, cooperation and initiative.
REFERENCES
Ainanur, A., & Tirtayasa, S. (2018). Pengaruh Budaya
Organisasi, Kompetensi dan Motivasi Terhadap Kinerja Karyawan. Maneggio:
Jurnal Ilmiah Magister Manajemen, 1(1), 1�14.
Ansen, Y., & Norman, E. (2016). Hambatan Komunikasi Dan
Budaya Guna Meningkatkan Produktivitas Kerja. Study & Management
Research, 23.
Ayu, R. (2020). Analisis Kinerja Pegawai Pada Kantor Camat
Kampar Kabupaten Kampar. Universitas Islam Negeri Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau.
Dahlan, D., Hasim, D., & Hamdan, H. (2017). Pengaruh
Manajemen Sumber Daya Manusia dan Budaya Organisasi Terhadap Kualitas Pelayanan
Pada Kantor Kecamatan Tamalate Kota Makassar. Jurnal Ad�ministrare, 4(2),
69�75.
Darim, A. (2020). Manajemen Perilaku Organisasi Dalam
Mewujudkan Sumber Daya Manusia Yang Kompeten. Munaddhomah: Jurnal Manajemen
Pendidikan Islam, 1(1), 22�40.
Edison, E., Riyanti, A. A., & Yustiana, D. (2016). Budaya
Organisasi Dalam Aspek Peningkatan Kinerja Karyawan (Studi Kasus Di Hotel
Perdana Wisata, Bandung). Tourism Scientific Journal, 1(2),
134�151.
Hariyanti, F. (2021). Pengaruh Karakteristik Individu dan
Komunikasi Internal Terhadap Kinerja Karyawan. Jurnal Entrepreneur Dan
Manajemen Sains. Vol, 2(1).
Lestari, A. (2022). Pengaruh Disiplin Kerja Dan Budaya
Organisasi Terhadap Kinerja Karyawan PT. Mitra Musi Mandiri Palembang.
Universitas Bina Darma.
Miftahudin, M. (2018). Strategi Pengembangan Sumber Daya
Manusia Dalam Meningkatkan Kinerja Karyawan. Tadbir: Jurnal Manajemen Dakwah,
3(2), 1�16.
Mujiatun, S. (2017). Pengaruh Pelatihan Dan Motivasi Kerja
Terhadap Kompetensi Pegawai Pada Kantor Regional VI Badan Kepegawaian Negara
Medan. Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Dan Bisnis, 15(1).
Nurmasitha, F. (2013). Pengaruh Kompetensi Pegawai Dan
Lingkungan Kerja Terhadap Kualitas Pelayanan (Studi pada Dinas Kependudukan dan
Pencatatan Sipil Kabupaten Sidoarjo). Brawijaya University.
Purwitasari, H. Y. (2021). Pengaruh Religiusitas, Budaya
Organisasi, Pengendalian Internal, Disiplin, Dan Insentif Terhadap Kinerja
Karyawan Badan Usaha Milik Daerah (BUMD) Kabupaten Klaten.
Rohida, L. (2018). Pengaruh era revolusi industri 4.0
terhadap kompetensi sumber daya manusia. Jurnal Manajemen Dan Bisnis
Indonesia, 6(1), 114�136.
Rostiana, E., & Iskandar, I. (2020). Pengaruh Kompetensi
dan Kompensasi Terhadap Kinerja Karyawan Di PT. Gembala Sriwijaya Jakarta. Service
Management Triangle: Jurnal Manajemen Jasa, 2(1).
Suryadinata, L. F. (2015). Pengaruh Budaya Organisasi, Iklim
Organisasi Dan Motivasi Kerja Terhadap Kinerja Dosen (Studi pada Sekolah Tinggi
Ilmu Kesehatan Yarsi Mataram). JMM UNRAM-Master Of Management Journal, 4(3).
Yantika, Y., Herlambang, T., & Rozzaid, Y. (2018).
Pengaruh Lingkungan Kerja, Etos Kerja, Dan Disiplin Kerja Terhadap Kinerja
Karyawan (Studi Kasus Pada Pemkab Bondowoso). Jurnal Manajemen Dan Bisnis
Indonesia, 4(2), 174�188.
|
|
|