THE IMPACT
OF BANK DIRECT MARKETING ON ENROLLMENT INTENTION :
OPENING
BANK ACCOUNT
Dedy Hendrianto1, Tunjung
Hermawanto2, Evi Rinawati Simanjuntak3
Universitas Bina Nusantara, Jakarta
Barat, Indonesia
[email protected]1, [email protected]2, [email protected]3
![]()
ABSTRACT
The aim of this research is to further explore the characteristics of
marketers that are appropriate for enhancing trust and significantly
influencing customers' purchase intentions. The method used in this study is
quantitative. Non-probability sampling was used to select a sample of 233
participants. The data analysis technique employed in this research is
Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) Partial Least Squares (PLS). The results of
the study indicate that product knowledge, friendliness, and communication
skills have a positive impact on perceived trust, which in turn stimulates
customers' interest in opening a bank account. This study highlights the
crucial role of perceived trust as a mediator in this relationship, providing
insights for banking institutions to enhance their marketing strategies. For
instance, effective communication with the public regarding recognition,
awards, company performance, and empowering credible influencers can be
beneficial. Additionally, it is noteworthy that product knowledge emerges as
the most influential independent variable in shaping perceived trust.
Therefore, organizations are encouraged to enhance their marketers' product
knowledge through various means such as training, personal experiences, Q&A
forums, mentoring, coaching, and attractive incentives.
Keywords: product
knowledge, affability, communication skill, perceived trust, enrollment
intention
![]()
Corresponding Author: Evi Rinawati Simanjuntak
E-mail: [email protected]
INTRODUCTION
The banking sector faced challenges due to several
factors, including fluctuations in interest rates and the devaluation of the
rupiah against foreign currencies. As a result, Bank Indonesia, the monetary
authority, responded by increasing the BI rate. This move heightened
competition among banks to attract and retain third-party funds from customers.
Consequently, people became more discerning about where they save their money,
leading to fierce competition between Indonesian banks, particularly in terms
of marketing high-quality and reliable products and services. The primary role
of banking is to gather and distribute public funds, acting as an intermediary
between those with excess funds and those in need. Banks gain trust from the
precautionary principle that is applied because trust is the main keyword for
the development of a bank (Manurung &
Rahardja, 2004).
With the increasing role of the financial sector, the
need for improved marketing management in financial services is also
increasing. The effect of marketing on consumer purchasing decisions in various
cases, and this research revealed that marketing has a positive influence on
consumer purchasing decisions (El Amrani &
Correard, 2011). In advertising and product promotion, two main
approaches are used in practice: mass (indirect) marketing and direct
marketing. Mass marketing uses mass media to broadcast product-related
information to current and potential customers. The mass media marketers use
include television, radio, magazines, and newspapers. Mass marketing targets
large customer groups. It does not discriminate between customers in a group,
and the information conveyed to customers is uniform. According to research,
direct marketing differs from mass marketing because it targets specific
individuals or households so that different customers will receive different
marketing information (Wang et al., 2009). The Direct Marketing Association (DMA) defines
direct marketing as communication in which data is used systematically to
achieve measurable marketing objectives and when direct contact occurs between
a company and customers or potential customers.
The effect of direct marketing and advertising on
customer enrollment intention in applying for consumer loans for civil servants
in one of the BUMDs (Rawung et al., 2015). The results of the study showed that direct
marketing and advertising had a positive influence on customer enrollment
intentions. Research shows that direct marketing has several advantages, such
as high flexibility in adapting to changing environments, being able to develop
an extensive database of customers, obtaining a direct response, building
relationship with customers, and cost-effective due to less (a smaller) number
of intermediaries in the channel (Lim et al., 2022).
The current marketing environment is becoming
increasingly competitive and complex, where customer demands are the primary
consideration for determining a channel structure that suits customer desires.
In line with the financial sector's important role, financial services
marketing management experiences higher pressure to achieve success Despite the
recession, the financial services sector continues to grow in income and profits
and consequently significantly influences other areas of the economy (Wright et al., 2010). Thus, promotion techniques and strategies in
financial services are also constantly changing. Direct marketing involves
using telephone, mail, fax, e-mail, the internet, and other tools to directly
communicate the company's interests to customers (Armstrong et al.,
2014). Direct marketing is a marketing system that causes
companies or marketers to be able to communicate directly with consumers to
produce responses or transactions that are also direct. According to research,
the responses generated from direct marketing include inquiry, purchase, or
support for consumers in deciding an action (Ku Fan & Wen
Cheng, 2009). Marketers� success through direct marketing is
primarily determined by the company's and marketers� ability to select target
markets and design their direct marketing campaigns. The right market will
determine the effectiveness of the applied direct marketing, while designing a
unique, fun, and inspiring direct marketing campaign will determine the quality
of the used direct marketing.
Massive technological developments encourage
innovation in banking products that are more accessible, for example, opening a
digital account via a mobile phone without the need to visit a branch office.
However, on the other hand, digital literacy in Indonesia is still not evenly
distributed. According to the report "Digital Literacy Status in Indonesia
2021," released by the Ministry of Communication and Informatics, digital
literacy in Indonesia is at a moderate level with an uneven distribution. Revealed
in research that financial literacy is the knowledge and skills needed for
someone to make the right decisions based on their financial resources (Manurung &
Rahardja, 2004). This literacy ability can impact people�s success in
opening digital accounts, ultimately affecting their decision to buy or try
banking products. Based on internal data, the conversion rate for the
completion of savings openings to the number of installations is only around
5%. This shows that there are still many difficulties faced by prospective
customers when opening digital savings accounts independently. In Wang�s (1999)
approach, companies do not establish direct customer relationships for new
product offerings. Many customers are either uninterested or do not respond to
this sales promotion. Thus, banks, financial services companies, and others are
moving away from mass marketing strategies due to their ineffectiveness and
targeting a large proportion of their customers with direct marketing for
specific product and service offerings. This aligns with research by Zhong and
Liu (2003), who found that direct marketing is the primary strategy of many
banks and insurance companies to interact with customers.
The success or failure of an organization is primarily
determined by performance (Podsakoff &
MacKenzie, 2014). Therefore, measuring or improving the sales force�s
performance must be one of the sales manager's priorities. Similarly, research
showed that a commercial organization's performance depends on salespeople's
performance (Ferdinand &
Wahyuningsih, 2018). Hence, an essential management task is determining
what characteristics drive sales force performance. This research will focus on
examining marketers' characteristics that significantly affect perceived trust
and customer enrollment intention. The communication skills, product knowledge,
presentation skills, flexibility, empathy, and honesty are the most critical
factors (Amor, 2019). Research shows that the essential characteristics of
a salesperson are being helpful, having good product knowledge, and being able
to communicate in a friendly manner with customers (Fergurson et al.,
2021). Meanwhile, Cohen & Prusak (2001) show that
affability and comfort do not necessarily generate trust. Nevertheless,
research to discuss the characteristics of marketers for digital banking
products has not been widely studied at this time. However, research focusing
on the characteristics of marketers in the digital banking products sector has
not been extensively explored. Therefore, this study aims to further explore
the appropriate marketer characteristics that enhance trust and significantly
influence customer purchase intentions. The benefits of this research include
increased customer trust. By understanding the characteristics of marketers
that establish trust, banking institutions can train and develop their
employees' skills to build stronger relationships with customers. Additionally,
it can enhance customer purchase interest; by understanding the factors
influencing customer purchase intentions, companies can design more effective
marketing campaigns. Furthermore, other benefits include providing information
that can assist companies in designing new products and services tailored to
customer needs and preferences, based on marketer characteristics that have
been proven successful in enhancing trust and purchase intentions.
METHOD
This quantitative
research examines the effect of direct marketing, which consists of product
knowledge, affability, and communication skills, on creating perceived trust.
The existence of perceived trust will be seen in its influence on
decision-making in opening banking customer savings accounts. Research
strategies were carried out using a quantitative survey approach, where data
collection was carried out through questionnaires from respondents using
standard research instruments (Sekaran & Bougie,
2016). The scope of this research was conducted on banking
customers who are domiciled in the banking work unit area in Indonesia to
determine marketers� ability to do so with minimal research interference.
Furthermore, the sample frame will be limited to male and female customers in
all areas of the bank's work units in Indonesia, with an age range of 18 to
> 50 years. In this study, the entire or a portion of the population was
selected from these individuals, and data were collected to help answer the research
questions (Olsen & St George,
2004).
The research
conducted was non-probability sampling, which considered the study period. In
contrast, the sampling method chosen was purposive sampling, where this
technique is also called judgmental sampling (Etikan et al., 2016). The sample size in this study is 233, considering the
minimum number of samples, which is 180. The data was
collected through an online
survey using a Google Form questionnaire distributed to the target population.
Respondents were asked to answer questions on a five-point Likert scale from 1
to 5, with responses ranging from "strongly disagree" to
"strongly agree," and provide general information consisting of
gender, age, and domicile. Based on the results of the questionnaire, its validity
and reliability were then tested.
Description of Respondent Characteristics
This research
involved 233 respondents as a whole. Based on the results of the data
collection in this study, the following is a description of the characteristics
of the respondents according to gender, occupation, and age: The results of the
analysis showed that of the 233 respondents who were examined in this study,
most were male (51.9%). In contrast, the remaining respondents were female
(48.1%. Furthermore, according to the type of work of the respondents, most of
the respondents worked as students (37.8%). In comparison, the rest worked as
private employees, as much as 27.0%, as much as 15.0% as civil servants/BUMN,
as much as 14.6% worked as entrepreneurs, and as many as 5.6 respondents did
not work. Furthermore, according to the age of the respondents, most of the
respondents were aged between 21 and 30 years (36.1%), while the respondents
aged 18�20 were as many as 27.9%, as many as 25.3% of respondents aged 31�40
years, as many as 7.3% of respondents aged 41�50 years, and as many as 3.4% of
respondents aged > 50 years.
Descriptive
analysis was carried out by calculating the mean score of respondents' answers
on each research variable. The average score of these answers is then categorized
into three categories according to Umar (2012), namely the low category if the
mean value is between 1.00 and 2.33; the medium category if the mean value is
between 2.33 and 3.67; and the high category if the mean value is between 3.67
and 5.00. Based on the results of completing the questionnaire, the following
is a description of the research variables consisting of product knowledge,
affability, communication skills, perceived trust, and enrollment intention:
Table 1. Description of Research Variables
|
Product Knowledge |
Affability |
Communication Skill |
Perceived Trust |
Enrollment intention |
|||||
|
Kode |
Mean |
Kode |
Mean |
Kode |
Mean |
Kode |
Mean |
Kode |
Mean |
|
PK1 |
3.373 |
AFF1 |
3.313 |
CS1 |
3.292 |
PT1 |
3.541 |
EI1 |
3.167 |
|
PK2 |
3.262 |
AFF2 |
3.219 |
CS2 |
3.335 |
PT2 |
3.103 |
EI2 |
3.056 |
|
PK3 |
3.489 |
AFF3 |
3.584 |
CS3 |
3.382 |
PT3 |
3.704 |
EI3 |
2.961 |
|
PK4 |
3.584 |
AFF4 |
3.167 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
PK5 |
3.433 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Average |
3.428 |
Average |
3.321 |
Average |
3.336 |
Average |
3.449 |
Average |
3.061 |
Product knowledge
is measured using five question items. The analysis results in Table 1 show
that overall product knowledge is good. However, in terms of knowledge about
product specifications, delivery of information about products, developments
about products, and features and benefits of products, there is still room for
improvement.
In this study,
affability was measured by four question items. The analysis results in Table 1
show that overall affability is good. However, it still needs improvement in understanding
different customer needs, non-verbal
communication with others, and the ability to influence others.
Three question
items measured communication skills in this study. The analysis results show
that overall the description of communication skills is good. However, all
three can still be improved in terms of presentation and speaking skills, both in terms of articulation and
effective word selection.
Three question
items measure perceived trust in this study. The analysis results in Table 1
show that overall perceived trust is good. However, it still needs to be
improved in terms of building product understanding and the ability to solve
consumer problems.
In this study,
enrollment intention is measured by three question items. Three question items
measured enrollment intention in this study. The analysis results in Table 1
show that overall enrollment intention is also good. However, all three are
still very likely to be improved regarding the suitability of product quality,
interesting information received, and trust in the information conveyed by the
salesperson.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In this study, testing the influence of the impact of
banking direct marketing on enrollment intention was carried out using SEM PLS
analysis. The stages in the PLS-SEM analysis consist of (1) drawing a path diagram
according to the research model framework; (2) performing outer model tests to
assess the validity and reliability of indicators in measuring the variables
(constructs); (3) assessing the goodness of fit of the model to ensure that the
processed data is fit with the estimated model so that the sample used can
provide an overview of the actual condition of the population; and (4)
conducting inner model testing, which is the stage of testing the effect of
inter-variables as a tool for testing research hypotheses (Hair et al., 2019). This research model contains five latent variables:
affability (AFF), communication skill (CS), enrollment intention (EI), product
knowledge (PK), and perceived trust (PT). The measurement model testing phase
includes composite reliability and convergence validity testing. The results of
the PLS analysis can be used to test the research hypothesis if all indicators
in the PLS model meet the requirements of convergent validity, discriminant
validity, and composite reliability. To bring up the results of the outer model
test, the PLS model must be estimated using an algorithmic technique. The
following is the estimation result of the PLS-SEM model after being estimated
using an algorithm technique.
Construct reliability can be assessed by Cronbach's alpha
value and the composite reliability value of each construct. The recommended
composite reliability and Crombach's alpha values are more significant than
0.7, but in development research, because the loading factor limit used is low
(0.5), low composite reliability and Crombach's alpha values can still be
accepted as long as the validity requirements converge and discriminant has
been met.
Table
2. Composite
Reliability
|
Cronbach's Alpha |
rho_A |
Composite Reliability |
|
|
AFF |
0.908 |
0.914 |
0.936 |
|
CS |
0.905 |
0.906 |
0.940 |
|
EI |
0.938 |
0.948 |
0.960 |
|
PK |
0.949 |
0.957 |
0.961 |
|
PT |
0.915 |
0.921 |
0.947 |
Based on the analysis results in Table 2 above, the
composite reliability and Cronbach's alpha values of all constructs have also
exceeded 0.7, indicating that all constructs have met the required reliability.
The discriminant validity test examined the HTMT
(heterotrait-monotrait ratio) values between constructs. HTMT is the
recommended alternative method for assessing discriminant validity. This method
uses a multitrait-multimethod matrix as the basis for measurement. The HTMT
value must be less than 0.9 to ensure discriminant validity between the two
reflective constructs (Henseler et al., 2015). In this test, the construct in the PLS model is
declared to have met discriminant validity if the HTMT value between the
construct and the other constructs does not exceed 0.9.
Table 3. The discriminant validity (HTMT)
|
AFF |
CS |
EI |
PK |
PT |
|
|
AFF |
|||||
|
CS |
0.700 |
||||
|
EI |
0.640 |
0.564 |
|||
|
PK |
0.729 |
0.733 |
0.737 |
||
|
PT |
0.762 |
0.732 |
0.716 |
0.808 |
Based on the results of the discriminant validity test
(Table 3), none of the HTMT values between constructs exceeds 0.9, which means
that all constructs in the PLS model (outer model) meet the required
discriminant validity criteria.
The goodness-of-fit model test is conducted to ensure
that the compiled PLS model fits with the data being analyzed to explain the
actual condition of the population. The goodness of fit of the PLS model can be
seen from the R Square value. R Square value > 0.67 indicates the PLS model
is robust in predicting endogenous, R Square 0.33�0.67 indicates the PLS model
is in the moderate category, and R Square 0.19�0.33 indicates that the PLS
model is weak in predicting endogenous (Chin, 1998).
Table 4. R Square
|
Variable |
R Square |
R Square Adjusted |
|
EI |
0.448 |
0.445 |
|
PT |
0.666 |
0.661 |
The analysis results in Table 4 show that the R square of
perceived trust (PT) of 0.666 is in the endogenous category, meaning that the
model is robust in predicting perceived trust (PT) from its exogenous sources. This
also can be seen from PLS-SEM algorithm model in Figure 2.

Figure 1. The estimation result of the PLS-SEM algorithm Model
The convergent validity test is carried out by looking at
the loading factor value of each indicator against the construct. Because this
research is a confirmatory study, the loading factor limit is 0.7. Based on the
estimation results of the SEM model in Table
5, all variables in the model are
valid.
Table
5. Convergent Validity
|
Variable |
Indicator |
Factor Loading |
Conclusion |
AVE |
Conclusion |
|
Product
Knowledge |
PK1 |
0.908 |
Valid |
0.832 |
Valid |
|
PK2 |
0.823 |
Valid |
|||
|
PK3 |
0.957 |
Valid |
|||
|
PK4 |
0.929 |
Valid |
|||
|
PK5 |
0.937 |
Valid |
|||
|
Affability |
AFF1 |
0.872 |
Valid |
0.787 |
Valid |
|
AFF2 |
0.937 |
Valid |
|||
|
AFF3 |
0.927 |
Valid |
|||
|
AFF4 |
0.806 |
Valid |
|||
|
Customer
Satisfaction |
CS1 |
0.884 |
Valid |
0.840 |
Valid |
|
CS2 |
0.941 |
Valid |
|||
|
CS3 |
0.924 |
Valid |
|||
|
Perceived
Trust |
PT1 |
0.952 |
Valid |
0.855 |
Valid |
|
PT2 |
0.879 |
Valid |
|||
|
PT2 |
0.942 |
Valid |
|||
|
Enrollment
Intention |
EI1 |
0.933 |
Valid |
0.890 |
Valid |
|
EI2 |
0.965 |
Valid |
|||
|
EI3 |
0.931 |
Valid |
Testing the Effect of
Variables
In PLS analysis, testing the effect between variables can
be done after the model is proven to fit. Testing the effect includes testing
the direct effect, testing the indirect effect, and testing the total effect.
The following is the estimation result of the PLS-SEM model using the
bootstrapping method:
Direct Influence
The direct effect, often referred to as the direct
effect," is the direct effect of exogenous variables on endogenous
variables. The significance and direction of direct influence in the PLS-SEM
analysis can be seen from the p-value, t-statistic, and path coefficients connecting
endogenous to exogenous. Suppose the p-value is�
0.05, and the T statistic is > 1.96 (t value two tails,� 5%). In that case, it can be concluded that
the exogenous variable significantly affects the endogen, with the direction of influence according to
the sign attached to the path coefficient. Furthermore, suppose the p-value is
> 0.05, and the T statistic is� 1.96
(t value two tails,� 5%). In that case,
it is concluded that the exogenous variable has no significant effect on the
endogen (Hair et al., 2019).
Table 6. Results of the Direct Effect Test
|
Original Sample (O) |
Sample Mean (M) |
Standard Deviation (STDEV) |
T Statistics (|O/STDEV|) |
P Values |
|
|
AFF ->
PT |
0.264 |
0.265 |
0.062 |
4.277 |
0.000 |
|
CS -> PT |
0.185 |
0.184 |
0.061 |
3.046 |
0.002 |
|
PK -> PT |
0.465 |
0.467 |
0.057 |
8.170 |
0.000 |
|
PT -> EI |
0.669 |
0.671 |
0.029 |
22.726 |
0.000 |
Based on the test
results, the following results were obtained:
1. Affability (AFF) and Perceived Trust (PT)
Affability
positively and significantly affects perceived trust, as indicated by sig. =
0.000� 0.05, T statistic 4.277 > 1.96,
and a positive path coefficient of 0.264, meaning that the higher the
affability, the higher the perceived trust, and vice versa, the lower the
affability, the lower the perceived trust.
2. Communication Skills (CS) and Perceived Trust (PT)
Communication
skill positively and significantly affects perceived trust, as indicated by
sig. = 0.002� 0.05, T statistic 3.046
> 1.96, and a positive path coefficient of 0.185, meaning that the higher
the communication skill, the higher the perceived trust, and vice versa, the
lower the communication skill, the lower the perceived trust.
3. Product Knowledge (PK) and Perceived Trust (PT)
Product
knowledge has a positive and significant effect on perceived trust, as
indicated by sig. = 0.000� 0.05, T statistic
8.170 > 1.96, and a positive path coefficient of 0.465, meaning that the
higher the product knowledge, the higher the perceived trust, and vice versa,
the lower the perceived trust.
4. Perceived Trust = Enrollment intention (EI)
Perceived
trust has a positive and significant effect on enrollment intention, as
indicated by sig. = 0.000� 0.05, T
statistic 22.726 > 1.96, and a positive path coefficient of 0.669, meaning
that the higher the perceived trust, the higher the enrollment intention, and
vice versa, the lower the perceived trust, the lower the enrollment intention.
Mediation Effect Testing
In this study, perceived
trust acts as a mediator. To test the role of mediation, a mediation test is
carried out as follows:
Table 7. Indirect Effect Test
|
Original
Sample (O) |
T
Statistics (|O/STDEV|) |
P Values |
|
|
AFF -> PT -> EI |
0.177 |
4.255 |
0.000 |
|
CS -> PT -> EI |
0.124 |
3.057 |
0.002 |
|
PK -> PT -> EI |
0.311 |
7.088 |
0.000 |
The explanation of the
results of the indirect influence test in Table 7 above is as follows:
1. Affability (AFF)�
Perceived Trust (PT)� Enrollment
intention (EI)
In the
indirect path, the influence of affability on enrollment intention through
perceived trust obtained a p-value of 0.000 with a T statistic of 4.255 and a
positive indirect path coefficient of 0.177 because the p-value obtained was
0.05 and the T statistic was > 1. It is concluded that affability can
indirectly affect enrollment intention, mediated by perceived trust. In this
PLS model, perceived trust is proven to mediate the indirect effect of
affability on enrollment intention.
2. Communication skill (CS), perceived trust (PT), and
enrollment intention (EI)
In the
indirect path, the effect of communication skills on enrollment intention
through perceived trust obtained a p-value of 0.002 with a T statistic of 3.057
and a positive indirect path coefficient of 0.124. Because the p-value obtained
is 0.05, and the T statistic is > 1.96, it can be concluded that
communication skills can indirectly affect enrollment intention mediated by
perceived trust. In this PLS model, perceived trust is proven to mediate the
indirect effect of communication skills on enrollment intention.
3. Product Knowledge (PK), Perceived Trust (PT), and
Enrollment intention (EI)
On the
indirect path of the effect of product knowledge on enrollment intention
through perceived trust, a p-value of 0.000 is obtained with a T statistic of
7.088 and a positive indirect path coefficient of 0.311. Because the p-value
obtained is 0.05, and the T statistic is > 1.96, it is concluded that
product knowledge can indirectly influence enrollment intention through
perceived trust. In this PLS model, perceived trust is proven to mediate the indirect
effect of product knowledge on enrollment intention.
Coefficient of determination
The coefficient of determination shows the contribution
of all exogenous factors to endogenous factors. The coefficient of
determination can be seen from the adjusted R square value. This value ranges
from 0 to 1 or can be interpreted as a percentage (0 to 100%). The greater the
coefficient of determination, the greater the endogenous variance explained by
the exogenous, while the small coefficient of determination indicates the low
influence of the exogenous on the endogenous. This is because there are still
quite several factors outside of these exogenous that can affect the
endogenous.
Table 8.� Coefficient of
determination
|
������������ Variable |
R Square |
R Square Adjusted |
|
EI |
0.448 |
0.445 |
|
PT |
0.666 |
0.661 |
The results of the analysis in Table 8 show that the
adjusted R squared value of 0.661 means that 66.1% of the perceived trust
variance is influenced by product knowledge, affability, and communication
skills, while the remaining 33.9% of the perceived trust variance is influenced
by other factors outside of product knowledge, affability, and communication
skills. Furthermore, on the enrollment intention variable, the adjusted R
square is 0.445, which means that 44.5% of the variance of enrollment intention
is influenced by perceived trust, and other factors outside of perceived trust
influence the remaining 55.5% of the variance of enrollment intention.
The results of this study proved that product knowledge
has a positive and significant effect on perceived trust, where the higher the
salesperson's product knowledge of the products offered will increase consumer
confidence in opening an account. Product knowledge is the variable that most
significantly affects customer trust compared to other variables studied based
on the path coefficient value, which is greater than the affability and
communication skill variables. This is in line with the research, which shows that
product knowledge is the variable with the most significant influence
(Siagian et al., 2020). These results show that a marketer with comprehensive knowledge about various bank products and
services instills consumer trust. Communicating various product choices' features,
benefits, and advantages builds trust. In addition, this product knowledge
enables marketers to answer questions that consumers may have, such as about
the security of deposit money, interest rates, and ease of transactions, which
can provide certainty and build consumer confidence. By having adequate product
knowledge, marketers can effectively communicate product advantages, answer
consumer questions, and provide appropriate recommendations for financial
solutions needed by prospective customers.
The affability variable also has a positive and
significant effect on perceived trust, where the friendlier a salesperson, the
greater the consumer's confidence in opening an account. These results indicate
that consumers are more likely to trust marketers who show a friendly attitude.
Friendly sellers can effectively listen to questions, understand consumers'
financial needs, and provide recommendations for effective banking solutions.
By combining friendliness with product knowledge, marketers can create a
powerful combination for instilling trust in consumers. The friendliness of a
seller plays an essential role in building consumer trust when opening a bank
account because it creates a positive impression, establishes good relations,
and fosters an open communication environment. This is similar to research
which shows that friendliness has a positive effect on customer trust
(Wasti & Tan, 2010). Research also revealed that customers who perceive
sellers as friendly and experts are more likely to trust them
(Zhang et al., 2016). That trust has a positive impact on enrollment
intention.
Communication skill has a positive and significant effect
on perceived trust, meaning that the higher the communication skill, the higher
the perceived trust, and vice versa, the lower the communication skill, the
lower the perceived trust. Effective communication is essential in building and
maintaining relationships with consumers. Marketers with solid communication
skills can convey information, listen well to consumers, and adapt their
communication style to understand the needs of each customer. Marketers build
consumer trust by informing consumers of the benefits and features of various
bank products in a concise and easy-to-understand manner. In addition, good
listening skills enable marketers to provide financial solutions that meet
consumer needs. Perceived trust, which is a moderating variable from the
influence of product knowledge, affability, and communication skills on
enrollment intention, has a positive and significant influence on enrollment
intention, meaning that the higher the perceived trust, the higher the
enrollment intention, and vice versa, the lower the perceived trust, the lower
the enrollment intention.
The results of this study are in line with the results of
research by Doney and Canon (1997), which show that communication made by
salespeople in business has a positive effect on trust in the salesperson, so
it will also have a positive effect on trust in the company where the
salesperson works. In addition, this research is also to Wartini's research
(2008), which proves that communication skills will build trust
(Siau & Wang, 2018). Research also shows that one of the communication
skills, such as listening to customers carefully, can increase customer trust
in marketers (Itani et al., 2019). The results of this study indicate that perceived trust
can mediate the indirect effect of product knowledge, affability, and
communication skills on enrollment intention. The results of this study support
the results of previous research conducted by (Moriuchi & Takahashi,
2016), which adopted trust as a mediator variable in studying
the relationship between marketing mix and online shopping behavior and found
that trust is a potent mediator or intervening variable. Their study shows that
trust can be a partial or complete mediator.Research found that customer trust has a mediator effect in their
study of Malaysia�s life insurance policy sector (Panigrahi et al., 2014). Trust was also found to have a mediating effect in a
study of restaurant business in Korea (Kim & Shim, 2018). In conclusion, trust is consumer behavior in which
consumers are willing to rely on and entrust a product or service and the
promises or information made by the seller.
CONCLUSION
The conclusion obtained from the results
of this study is that product knowledge, affability, and communication skills
affect perceived trust, and where perceived trust has a positive effect on
enrollment intention, this means that the higher the product knowledge,
affability, and communication skills of marketers, the higher the consumer
trust of the product to be purchased, which will further increase consumer
interest in buying the product. Perceived trust in this study is proven to
mediate the effect of product knowledge, affability, and communication skills
on enrollment intention. What can be done to increase perceived trust is to
communicate appropriately to the public about company recognition, rewards, and
performance and empower credible influencers. Based on the path coefficient value
in the direct effect test, product knowledge is the most potent variable in
influencing the emergence of perceived trust. Therefore companies need to
encourage to increase the capacity of marketers through various efforts of training,
personal experience, Q&A forums, coaching & mentoring, and attractive
incentives for marketers.
REFERENCES
Amor, N. (2019). What skills make a salesperson effective? An
exploratory comparative study among car sales professionals. International
Business Research, 12(11), 76�93.
Armstrong, G., Adam, S., Denize, S., & Kotler, P. (2014).
Principles of marketing. Pearson Australia.
El Amrani, H., & Correard, S. (2011). The impact of
marketing on customer�s behaviour: Influence or manipulation?
Etikan, I., Musa, S. A., & Alkassim, R. S. (2016).
Comparison of convenience sampling and purposive sampling. American Journal
of Theoretical and Applied Statistics, 5(1), 1�4.
Ferdinand, A. T., & Wahyuningsih, W. (2018). Salespeople�s
innovativeness: a driver of sales performance. Management & Marketing.
Challenges for the Knowledge Society, 13(2), 966�984.
Fergurson, J. R., Gironda, J. T., & Petrescu, M. (2021).
Salesperson attributes that influence consumer perceptions of sales
interactions. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 38(6), 652�663.
Hair, J. F., Ringle, C. M., Gudergan, S. P., Fischer, A.,
Nitzl, C., & Menictas, C. (2019). Partial least squares structural equation
modeling-based discrete choice modeling: an illustration in modeling retailer
choice. Business Research, 12, 115�142.
Henseler, J., Ringle, C. M., & Sarstedt, M. (2015). A new
criterion for assessing discriminant validity in variance-based structural
equation modeling. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 43,
115�135.
Itani, O. S., Goad, E. A., & Jaramillo, F. (2019). Building
customer relationships while achieving sales performance results: Is listening
the holy grail of sales? Journal of Business Research, 102, 120�130.
Kim, N., & Shim, C. (2018). Social capital, knowledge
sharing and innovation of small-and medium-sized enterprises in a tourism
cluster. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 30(6),
2417�2437.
Ku Fan, C., & Wen Cheng, S. (2009). An efficiency
comparison of direct and indirect channels in Taiwan insurance marketing. Direct
Marketing: An International Journal, 3(4), 343�359.
Lim, W. M., Kumar, S., Pandey, N., Rasul, T., & Gaur, V.
(2022). From direct marketing to interactive marketing: a retrospective review
of the Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing. Journal of Research in
Interactive Marketing, ahead-of-print.
Manurung, M., & Rahardja, P. (2004). Uang, perbankan, dan
ekonomi moneter. Kajian Kontekstual Indonesia). Jakarta: Lembaga Penerbit
FE-UI. Munawir.
Moriuchi, E., & Takahashi, I. (2016). Satisfaction trust
and loyalty of repeat online consumer within the Japanese online supermarket
trade. Australasian Marketing Journal, 24(2), 146�156.
Olsen, C., & St George, D. M. M. (2004). Cross-sectional
study design and data analysis. College Entrance Examination Board, 26(03),
2006.
Panigrahi, S., Zainuddin, Y., & Azizan, N. (2014).
Investigating key determinants for the success of knowledge management system
(KMS) in higher learning institutions of Malaysia using structural equation
modeling. The International Journal Of Humanities & Social Studies
(IJHSS), 2(6), 202�209.
Podsakoff, P. M., & MacKenzie, S. B. (2014). Impact of
organizational citizenship behavior on organizational performance: A review and
suggestions for future research. Organizational Citizenship Behavior and
Contextual Performance, 133�151.
Rawung, D. R., Oroh, S. G., & Sumarauw, J. S. B. (2015).
Analisis Kualitas produk, merek dan harga terhadap keputusan pembelian sepeda
motor Suzuki Pada PT. Sinar Galesong Pratama Manado. Jurnal EMBA: Jurnal
Riset Ekonomi, Manajemen, Bisnis Dan Akuntansi, 3(3).
Sekaran, U., & Bougie, R. (2016). Research methods for
business: A skill building approach. john wiley & sons.
Siagian, H., Putera, G., & Burlakovs, J. (2020). The
effect of product knowledge on salesperson performance with the moderating role
of attitude. EDP Sciences.
Siau, K., & Wang, W. (2018). Building trust in artificial
intelligence, machine learning, and robotics. Cutter Business Technology
Journal, 31(2), 47�53.
Wang, C.-C., Chen, C.-A., & Jiang, J.-C. (2009). The Impact
of Knowledge and Trust on E-Consumers� Online Shopping Activities: An Empirical
Study. J. Comput., 4(1), 11�18.
Wasti, S. A., & Tan, H. H. (2010). 12 Antecedents of
supervisor trust in collectivist cultures: evidence from Turkey and China. Organizational
Trust, 311.
Wright, M., Watkins, T., & Ennew, C. (2010). Marketing
financial services. Routledge.
Zhang, J. Z., Watson Iv, G. F., Palmatier, R. W., & Dant,
R. P. (2016). Dynamic relationship marketing. Journal of Marketing, 80(5),
53�75.
|
� 2023 by
the authors. Submitted for possible open-access publication under the terms
and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY SA) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/). |